The mystery of the side chapel saint

The restoration of a Mission-era painting reveals a decades-old case of mistaken identity.

The mystery of the side chapel saint
Let there be light: St. Cajetan revealed. Photo by Adam Hays

The youth’s gaze focuses intently upward, one hand clutching a white lily to his breast, but little else could be distinguished. The Mission-era portrait hanging in a side chapel of the Mission Santa Clara de Asís since 1929 was too obscured by grime to make out details.

Until recently.

“It’s a painting that I originally thought was ugly and nondescript and of little interest,” says Charles White, director of the Mission Church. “But the conservators kept arguing that it was a diamond in the rough. They said, ‘You don’t realize this is a beautiful picture, you just have to get through all the soot and the grime.’”


The Patron Saint of Job Seekers

Thanks to a grant from the California Missions Foundation, dedicated to the preservation and restoration of California’s 21 missions, those conservators got the chance to restore the painting in 2012. They carefully removed layers of severely darkened varnishes mixed with dust and soot. Their work revealed the subtle colors and exquisite details of the original artwork, most likely painted in Mexico in the early or mid-19th century. They also uncovered a mystery: The saint was not who everyone thought he was.

“Our earliest Mission guidebook, written in the late 1930s by Fr. James Walsh and based on the notes of SCU historian Arthur Spearman, S.J., believed the painting depicted St. Aloysius Gonzaga, the patron saint of college students,” White says. After the disastrous campus fire of 1926, alumnus Luis Fatjo 1893 made a donation for a side altar in the newly rebuilt Mission. It is here where the painting was hung.

Revelation: The painting as it looked before restoration (right half) and after (left half). Photos courtesy Charles White
Revelation: The painting as it looked before restoration (right half) and after (left half). Photos courtesy Charles White

St. Aloysius is often shown with a lily in his hand, signifying purity. The patron saint of students, he is usually portrayed as a beardless youth in an unadorned cassock. “The conservation revealed a slightly older figure with a mature man’s beard, adorned with richly gilded necklaces and matching belt,” White says. SCU President Michael Engh, S.J., a scholar of religious history, and longtime campus historian Gerald McKevitt, S.J., quickly realized the portrait was of someone other than Aloysius.

In his free time, Fr. Engh began checking books of Spanish colonial-era religious art for a match. He found paintings of San Cayetano—or, in English, St. Cajetan—a likely fit. In the early 16th century, Cajetan, an Italian diplomat, became a Catholic priest and Church reformer, drawing on his personal family fortune to build hospitals and loan agencies serving the poor. Known as the patron saint of job seekers, Cajetan is often depicted with a jeweled necklace instead of a simple black cassock. After viewing a variety of images of St. Cajetan, Frs. Engh and McKevitt became convinced he was the subject of the portrait.

The painting is among the last of the Mission’s artifacts that stood in need of restoration. “The statues and paintings are part of the Catholic religious heritage of our campus—and the state of California,” Fr. Engh says. “Charlie’s care of our patrimony deserves accolades from all who come to the Mission, from Santa Clara students at Mass to fourth-graders who visit to study California history for their classes.”

As graduation draws near, students picking up their sheepskins might also want to express some gratitude to White and the restorers. And perhaps they’ll pay a visit to the patron saint of job seekers in all his newly brilliant colors.

First-Time Grads

Overcoming all odds due to the pandemic, the Class of ’24 finally get to experience the graduation that they have long been waiting for.

Drumroll, Please!

Santa Clara University’s renovated jazz studio gives music majors and non-majors more space to find their sound.

A Plan For Tomorrow

Santa Clara President Julie Sullivan unveils a new strategic plan, Impact 2030, with a focus on increasing access and opportunity, and, of course, SCU’s Jesuit values and Silicon Valley location.