As told by Figini, 12 Broncos and a woman from San Jose State University took part in the late night heist, making off with the entire contents of the USF trophy case as a prank.
Raymond Kelly, S.J., dean of men and later vice president of student affairs, caught onto the shenanigans and, through “the mysterious ways” of the Jesuits, was able to name all of the Broncos involved.
A détente was arranged by the offices of student affairs at the two Bay Area Jesuit university rivals, and two weeks after they were taken, the SCU student body president returned the trophies to his USF counterpart at an undisclosed location.