Still, Johnston was skeptical. As she put it, “That’s what the media said she said. I didn’t hear it that way … My career started with injuries to others. I just had to be ready to play.”
She described the entire experience as “fighting and fighting and fighting for a spot.” When she finally earned the spot, she was more than ready.
In Canada, she anchored the backline that became the strength of the team. As the Americans struggled to score early in the World Cup, they faced increasing criticism and skepticism back at home. But thanks to the defensive efforts of Johnston, Becky Sauerbrunn, Meghan Klingenberg, and Ali Krieger—along with goalkeeper Hope Solo behind them—they stayed in every game. After giving up a goal in the opening game against Australia, they never allowed another through group play and into the knockout rounds as they headed for the final.
For those unfamiliar with the newcomer on the team, the sight of Johnston’s distinctive platinum ponytail bobbing on the backline soon became a visual security blanket. She cleared balls, shut down forwards, sprinted up to the opponent’s goal on set pieces—her white-blond hair and bright, wide headband making an excellent target. In short, Johnston was everywhere: physical, confident, and helping the defense keep the team in contention.
She never felt too young but rather an integral part of the unit.
“I felt a connection with the other players on the backline from the beginning,” Johnston says. “We held each other accountable. We had each other’s back.”
That was particularly important in the semifinal game against Germany, a two-time World Cup champion and the team expected to contend for the title. In the 59th minute of the scoreless game, Johnston pulled down midfielder Alexandra Popp inside the box. She earned a yellow card, and Germany earned a penalty kick. Johnston was clearly beside herself on the field.
It was “one of a defender’s worst nightmares,” Johnston said later. “The emotion. Just the possibility that I hurt my team, and it was on my shoulders.”
But her teammates rallied around her on the field. And, in a stunning development, Celia Sasic pulled the penalty kick wide, the first penalty kick miss in Germany’s history at the Women’s World Cup. The Americans went on to win 2–0 to advance to the final. Johnston was still teary talking to reporters after the game.
But by the final against Japan in Vancouver, she was back to being the confident, composed player. The high white-blond ponytail was again a talisman of defensive prowess. The team throttled Japan, though the defense’s scoreless streak of 513 minutes without allowing a goal was snapped in the second half. The United States won its first World Cup since 1999, beating Japan 5–2.
The American youngster ended up on the short list for the tournament’s highest honor, the Golden Ball, evidence of how highly regarded Johnston was during the World Cup. Lloyd received the honor, but Johnston’s ability with the ball both at her feet and on her head—and her toughness and savvy—offered one of the eye-opening performances of the World Cup. She drew rave reviews from veterans like Solo, Lloyd, and Abby Wambach for her poise and ability on the field.
Smith had confidence in her, too—but he knows how essential experience is to playing at the highest level. “It was really almost unprecedented for someone to have so few caps and go on to become such an integral part of a World Cup winning team,” he says. “To do as well as she did was really remarkable.”
The entire experience was remarkable. Hordes of Americans, many driving campers and making a summer vacation out of it, flowed across the border to Canada to see the games. The crowds were intensely pro-American. Everywhere you looked fans were wearing USA jerseys—including Johnston’s boyfriend, Ertz, who headed to Canada after Eagles minicamp and proudly donned a No. 19 jersey.
“There’s something so beautiful about representing your country,” Johnston says. “When all the States can come together and root for the same team, I could really feel that sense of pride.”
“So much of our motivation came from fans. Every stadium felt like a home-field advantage. It was unbelievable.”
The final game drew an audience of 25.4 million viewers, smashing the previous record as the most watched soccer game—male or female—in the history of the United States. The viewership was larger than the deciding game of the NBA Finals and Game 7 of the previous World Series.
The adulation continued through the summer.
“I’ve never had fan mail before,” Johnston says. “I try to answer some every day.”
Smith saw Johnston in late August, when the Broncos swung through the Midwest for games against Notre Dame and Northwestern. He has coached many of the national team players at various levels and has tracked their development over the years. And he notes that most young players first experience the biggest tournament in the world as a substitute.
“Most players barely play in their first World Cup,” Smith says. As for Johnston, “She didn’t have any of that. I’m sure it’s been overwhelming.”
NEXT STOP—RIO?
After the World Cup victory, Johnston returned to the Chicago Red Stars and saw a tremendous bump in attendance. Games were sold out, autograph lines were longer. Her team finished ranked second in the league and made its first postseason run in September, falling to FC Kansas City.